Estimated reading time 2 minutes 2 Min

Big Ten wins playoff selection derby, followed by SEC despite notable Alabama omission

College football’s conference shakeup left concerns about two super conferences dominating the playoff field.

9 December 2024
By JOHN ZENOR
9 December 2024

College football's conference shakeup left concerns about two super conferences dominating the playoff field.

They weren't totally unfounded or 100% borne out, either. The Big Ten, not the Southeastern Conference, was the biggest winner on Sunday. The ACC scored, too.

The Big Ten led the initial 12-team playoff field with four programs making the cut, led by a No. 1 Oregon (13-0) team that was part of the Pac-12 exodus.

Then came the SEC - and one notable omission. ACC runner-up SMU got the nod over college football blue-blood Alabama, another blemish in Kalen DeBoer's first season as Nick Saban's championship-or-bust successor. Another ego blow: The Mustangs are led by Rhett Lashlee, a former offensive coordinator at rival Auburn.

The Big Ten also got in No. 6 seed Penn State (11-2), No. 8 seed Ohio State (10-2) and No. 10 seed Indiana (11-1). The SEC represented well too: No. 2 seed Georgia (11-2), No. 5 seed Texas (11-2) and No. 9 seed Tennessee (10-2).

But the ACC proved it wasn't a one-bid league.

Clemson (10-3) - the final No. 12 seed with an overall No. 16 CFP ranking - earned the ACC's automatic bid with a 34-31 win in the title game over No. 11 seed SMU (11-2), which was close enough to impress the playoff committee and help the Mustangs edge out the Crimson Tide.

The odd man out among Power Four leagues: The Big 12, which unsurprisingly only advanced its champion, Arizona State (11-2) - ranked No. 12 overall by the CFP but awarded the No. 4 seed as the league title winner.

The SEC was left with Alabama, South Carolina and Mississippi on the wrong side of the bubble.

Mountain West Conference champion Boise State (12-1) got a No. 3 seed and first-round bye. No. 7 seed Notre Dame (11-1), an independent, had no chance to grab a bye despite a No. 5 final CFP ranking. The Fighting Irish at least get to host a first-round game against the in-state Hoosiers.

More Top Stories